If you know me at all, you know I’m an
Apple product “junkie”. I have an
iMac,
Macbook, and an
iPod Touch. I use
iWork Software (Pages, Keynote, and Numbers) instead of Microsoft Word, PowerPoint, and Excel. I love Apple products. I love the service I get when I visit an Apple store or when I call their toll free customer service number. I get personal attention without feeling pressured by a salesperson who wants the commission on my purchase! So naturally, I was excited to see the unveiling of their latest creation – the
iPad. After giving the
iPad some thought, I decided I’d share my thoughts, from the perspective of someone who writes a lot… and also reads a lot.
Is it way cool? YES! Would I like one? OF COURSE! Am I going to invest in one? Probably not. And here’s why.
First, I can’t imagine using the device for writing. In order to use it for any sort of word processing, the device would have to lay flat and the user would have to look down at it, rather than looking straight ahead the way you do with a conventional computer screen. And even with a conventional computer, many people (me included) still experience occasional (or even frequent) neck and shoulder pain. Now, I can certainly see why someone who doesn’t do a lot of writing or word processing would love an
iPad. For those who use their computers mainly for internet, digital pictures, etc., the
iPad is really cool, really convenient, and pretty cost efficient. Would I consider an
iPad if I could hook it up to an external keyboard for writing? Maybe. But factor in the added expense of purchasing a keyboard and the need to plug it in and “set it up” every time I wanted to write, and I might as well buy a
MacBook. Which I already have… and love.
Second, speculation has been touted about the
iPad giving Amazon’s
Kindle a run for its money. The
iPad will feature an e-reader application, as well as iBooks, an e-book store. Here’s my take – as both an Apple product “junkie” and a
Kindle owner. First of all, until I bought my
Kindle, I had read exactly ONE e-book. I downloaded it to my
MacBook in .pdf format and read it from my computer screen. While I liked the book, I did not enjoy reading it from my computer screen. Additionally, I’ve read a number of books or book-excerpts from my fellow-writers (for purposes of critiquing) on my computer screen. I find it difficult to read from the screen, and many times just print the pages so I can read them on paper. Eventually the lighting starts to irritate my eyes, sometimes even giving me a headache and reminding me of my days in college and grad school when I spent long periods of time working on research papers! I’ve owned my
Kindle for almost a year now, and I’ve lost count of the number of e-books I’ve purchased and read. The
Kindle screen is not a computer screen. It is not back-lit. It does not irritate my eyes. It is very much like looking at an actual page in an actual book. While the e-reader application might be useful for those who use an
iPad as their “computer”, I can’t imagine myself spending the money to purchase an
iPad specifically for that purpose. And with a price ranging from $499 to $829 (compared to
Kindle’s $250), purchasing the
iPad for the sole purpose of an e-reader doesn’t add up. I own an
iPod Touch, and I have downloaded Amazon’s free
Kindle application. I can move books from my
Kindle to my
iPod and back again. However, I’ve yet to read a book from my
iPod. Granted, it’s a much smaller screen than the
iPad, but even with a larger screen, I imagine I’d still chose to read from my
Kindle.
So, my conclusion is this… If the
iPad meets your computer needs, it’s an awesome product, and a good deal. If you don’t spend a lot of time writing/typing or working on word-processing, spreadsheets, etc., the portability, cost, and uniqueness make it a great choice. And if it meets your computer needs, the e-reader application is a bonus. If it can be your computer AND your preferred e-reader… YAY!
However, if you’re like me, and you spend time writing/typing, the
iPad might not meet your computer needs. My money is better spent on (and my needs better met by) a
MacBook, which is both portable and ergonomically better for purposes of writing. And since the
MacBook better suits my computer needs, and reading from my computer screen is not desirable, Amazon’s
Kindle is a better fit for my e-reading.
Sure purchasing even the most expensive
iPad would be less expensive than purchasing a
MacBook AND a
Kindle, but if the
iPad isn’t going to meet my needs, I’d rather spend the extra dollars and have products that are an exact fit.
What are your thoughts on the
iPad, particularly those of you who write? Do any of you own other e-readers (
Sony,
Nook, etc.)? How do you think your e-reader will compare to the
iPad’s e-reading application? Those of you who, like me, really love
Apple products… would you buy the
iPad and write from it? Would you buy the
iPad in addition to a laptop or desktop computer?
I’m interested in your opinions… so share!